Dividends to the holding, AHV contributions for the company
A medical practice paid its dividends to its owner's holding and paid him a salary of CHF 86,040. The Federal Supreme Court confirmed that part of those dividends is salary.
Contributions to the AHV, the Swiss old-age and survivors' insurance, are charged on earned income and not on investment income (Articles 4 and 5 AHVG, the act on old-age and survivors' insurance). A dividend is investment income. To an owner who works in their own company, a low salary and a high dividend can therefore look attractive.
The Federal Supreme Court recalls this in a judgment of 25 June 2026, and adds that on tax alone the choice is a disadvantage overall, because the same profit is taxed in the company and, in part, again as a dividend. The judgment concerns a case in which a holding stood between the company and its owner.
The case
A doctor converts his sole proprietorship into a company limited by shares, entered in the commercial register on 9 January 2017. On 5 July 2017 a limited liability company of which he is the only member, a holding, is registered, and on the same day it takes over all one hundred shares of the practice. In 2021 and 2022 the practice distributes dividends of CHF 582,000 and CHF 650,000 to the holding. It pays the doctor a salary of CHF 86,040 a year.
In November 2023 the compensation office, the body that collects the contributions, has the employer audited. The report finds dividends above 10% of the tax value of the shares and an owner who works full time. The office adds CHF 265,208 to his salary for the two years and claims the contributions in arrears with default interest. On objection it reduces the amount added to CHF 197,390: CHF 99,044 for 2021 and CHF 98,346 for 2022, the difference between the salary paid and the salary usual in the sector, about CHF 185,000.
The Insurance Court of the Canton of St. Gallen upholds this on 4 August 2025. The Federal Supreme Court dismisses the company's appeal in judgment 9C_532/2025.
The rule, which is not new
Whether a payment is salary or dividend depends on its nature and function, not on what the company calls it. The authorities depart from the split the company has chosen only where there is an obvious disproportion, and two are needed together: a salary that is inappropriately low compared with what is usual in the sector, and a dividend that is obviously excessive, above 10% of the value of the shares.
This is settled case law, which the judgment cites (BGE 141 V 634 and BGE 145 V 50). Up to this point the holding plays no part.
What changes with a holding in between
Nothing, if the holding is only a channel. The practice's dividends went to another legal entity, and the cantonal court first had to decide whether they could be attributed to the doctor. It did so by looking at what the holding actually did:
- It paid no salaries.
No salary subject to AHV contributions was accounted for at the holding.
- It lived on a single shareholding.
96.5% of its income came from the medical practice.
- The money went on to the owner.
The holding had borrowed a little over CHF 650,000 from the practice and at once lent the doctor almost CHF 1,200,000. Between dividends and loans, most of the money that came from the practice passed on to the doctor.
- The property was not enough.
The holding managed an apartment building, but with very low net income. The cantonal court did not see in it a significant business of its own.
The company named property management and succession as the holding's purposes, but relied essentially on the articles of association and gave no reasons for them. The Federal Supreme Court found no plausible reason for the structure and upheld the cantonal conclusion: the main purpose of the holding was to collect the practice's profits and pass them on to the doctor.
On the principle it adds a remark. The doctrine under which the separation between a company and the shareholder who controls it is disregarded was developed for questions of liability in company law. The idea behind it is nonetheless a general one: that separation is set aside, by way of exception, where it is a legal fiction that in no way corresponds to reality.
A holding that collects the dividends and passes them on to its owner does not change what they are.
Two details that weighed
- The working time.
The company said the doctor was employed at 50%. The audit report recorded 100%, on the basis of what the company's own tax advisers had told the auditors. The cantonal court observed that a practice with two doctors at 50% each does not normally employ an administrative manager and seven medical practice assistants, and that as a sole proprietor the doctor had earned about half a million a year. The Federal Supreme Court found nothing arbitrary in this.
- The amount of the salary.
CHF 86,040 is exactly the average annual income that, under the federal pension tables, gives the right to the maximum AHV pension. The Federal Supreme Court notes that paying a doctor CHF 172,080 for full-time work is not in itself abusive. The coincidence may nonetheless count at least as an indication that contributions played a part when the salary was set.
What the judgment does not say
It does not say that a personal holding is suspect, and it sets no minimum salary for an owner. The company did not dispute the principle that a dividend paid to an interposed holding can be salary subject to contributions, and it disputed neither that CHF 86,040 was inappropriate for full-time work nor the amounts added. The Federal Supreme Court checked that the facts found in St. Gallen were not manifestly incorrect, and the judgment has to be read within those limits.
It does say clearly what a compensation office looks at when a holding stands between the company and the person who works in it: what the holding does, where its income comes from, and where the money goes.
Three questions for anyone with a similar structure
- Does my salary stand comparison?
The benchmark is the salary usual in the sector for the same function and the same working time, the one the company would pay to a third party.
- Is the dividend above 10% of the value of the shares?
Below that threshold the question does not arise. Above it, it arises only if the salary is also inappropriate: the two conditions are cumulative.
- Does the holding do something of its own?
Other shareholdings, a business, staff, a reason that can be documented with more than the articles of association. And it matters where the money goes after the holding has received it.
Sources
Federal Supreme Court, judgment 9C_532/2025 of 25 June 2026, on appeal from the Insurance Court of the Canton of St. Gallen, AHV 2025/3 of 4 August 2025. The judgment is in German; the passages reported here are our translation.
Federal Act on Old-Age and Survivors' Insurance (AHVG, SR 831.10), arts. 4 and 5. Ordinance on Old-Age and Survivors' Insurance (AHVV, SR 831.101), art. 7(h). Federal Social Insurance Office, Guidelines on the salary subject to contributions in the AHV, IV and EO (WML), nos. 2010 and 2011, as cited in the judgment.
BGE 134 V 297, BGE 141 V 634 and BGE 145 V 50, cited in the judgment.
This article is general information and is not individual tax or legal advice. Whether a dividend is salary subject to contributions depends on the facts of each case.
This article is general information current at the date of publication. It is not advice in an individual case, and the treatment of any particular structure depends on its facts.
Salary and dividend, read together.
Tell us what salary and what dividends your company pays, and we will look at them with you.